Skip to main content

Manchester United and Success – It’s Complicated!


 

People see football as a beautiful leveler. Success unlike in some other professions is not an abstract term here. Success means victories, trophies etc. Failures means defeats, relegations etc. Simple isn’t it. Well not really, not when you put the term Football in between Manchester United & Club.

In the Sir Alex era, a successful season was a season that ended with the PL title is his grasp. Any addition to the trophy cabinet meant, we would add adjectives like great, historic to the season. Simple as football was always meant to be. But the post Sir Alex era Manchester United Football Club is in a complicated relationship with success.

If for Jose’s happiness we count the Community Shield as a trophy, then each of Moyes, LVG and the ‘trophy one’ himself have picked up something with a ribbon around them. Will they be remembered as successful United managers in the league of Sir Matt and Sir Alex - definitely not.

And then comes Ole, 4 months a super sub, 24 months a starter, zero trophies. He may win a trophy in the next two months or we will wait for atleast another 8 odd months (yes you carabao). Yet a majority of fans deem him the best United manager in the post Sir Alex era. And that is where the meltdown of the naysayers begins.

The thing is that as fans watching Ole’s version of United, we are like that professional who isn’t getting career growth but is being kept satisfied with some form of hope. The reason is that Jose while sometimes saying the truth, made us feel angry about United. Just like how Moyes made us feel shocked and LVG made us feel sleepy. However, Ole’s United starts by a manager who reminds us why we became United fans in the first place. It’s tugging on to an emotional happy memory of the good old days.

The journey with Ole is a proper roll coaster one. With regards to players, you find some new heroes and villains. You get excited whenever we counterattack but baffled whenever we have to breakdown a low block. Overall, you witness some incredible comebacks, but some miserable defeats as well. You can’t quite understand are we progressing or regressing. On one hand you like his man-management but are critical of his in-game management. Similarly, you like the fact the players aren’t being given robotic instructions w.r.t positions on the pitch, but on the other hand you wonder if all of them are intelligent enough to be situationally aware. You like the coaching staff and the new technical director because of their love for United, but you wonder if they have the skill to bring back the elusive ‘success.’

There is one foreboding thing you feel more strongly than ever since that fateful day in May 2013 – HOPE. Everytime Bruno cups his ears, everytime Shaw channels his inner Roberto Carlos, every intercept from Scott, every run from Marcus, every header from Slab, every tackle from Aaron, every goal from Mason - it gives you hope. Hope that despite having bad owners, there is a bunch of players and coaches who will give their all for you. Hope that the endless potential of our youth teams will translate into something serious. Hope that the new football structure will finally prioritize squad building over money spent. Hope that every defeat is a learning and every victory is a foundation. Hope that something sustainable might finally be being built.

Some fans will cling on to this hope and feel a sense of gratification if the current model takes us back to being Premier League champions. There will be other fans who would want instant gratification. Both aren’t wrong, both are just navigating the complicated relationship that Manchester United has with success in the post Sir Alex era.

 


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Let's Make MUFC Pragmatic Again!

  Aspirational or Pragmatic, two simple words but with colossal repercussions when applied to the Great Manchester United Managerial Race. I have to admit like most United fans, I have long craved a proactive manager with a well-placed attacking philosophy. It’s why I am allured by the prospect of Ten Hag and dream of the possibility of Enrique. But one look at Ralf’s time in charge is enough to move the needle from aspirations of what Manchester United should be and the reality of Manchester United will continue to be. For this is a club that hired not just a club builder but one of the most proactive managers of all time and turned him into a pragmatist. Is it Ralf’s fault? No, Is it the club’s fault? Not entirely. Although the club have been lucky that this is a far more grey-haired Ralf, someone who has the maturity to adapt to the design of the squads. And that part right there is the quality that Manchester United should prioritize the most as they search for managerial c...

Rock Bottom

  A United fan I know, is also a psychiatrist by profession (yup wh at a tr uly relevant field f ull of case studies!). During our in-game zoom calls with other fans (some of whom are good friends now, yup misery and joy both act as great unifiers), he said something really relevant…this was rock bottom. It’s a way to make people look on the bright side after bitter disappointment. But, such is the tribal nature of football, all it needs is for one of your rivals to hit rock bottom…for you to temporarily escape your own emotional hellhole! Everything that has followed this football club since that fateful  day at Leicester has been pretty bizzare. The sheer relief of being back amongst the big boys, fo llowed by what was a strange Europa league campaign. We wanted to win it, but would contrive to lose it. Then the club captains gets himself into a strange circus of who dun ‘nit in Greece, Mason our wonderboy goes bonkers in Iceland and all this while the board is putting us ...

Something is broken in football and it doesn’t look like it will ever be repaired

No, I am not talking about VAR, Football Authorities, Inflated Transfer Markets, Players, Coaches or Club Executives. I am talking about us, the football fan.  During the lockdown, every stadium has displayed ‘Football is nothing without the fans’. While that is correct, today it’s the fans who are ruining the game. Sounds cruel, well asks the players how they feel, when they read what there own fans write to them on certain platforms. The term ‘reactionary fan base’ was coined by the hardcore loyalists to distance themselves from the volatile fans that surrounded them on different platforms. Terms like ‘agenda merchants’ have also been developed to define the reactions of certain fans. Actually, this is where the trouble really started, the division of the football fan base within a club has deepened since the turn of the millennium and has only accelerated further in the last decade. I see today the first tendency is to blame an increasingly connected world for giving a platform ...